Now accepting Telehealth appointments. Schedule a virtual visit.

Choosing an ACL Graft – What is YOUR Best Option?

If you’ve torn your ACL and you are debating surgery, deciding on the type of graft to use to reconstruct the ligament can be a source of significant anxiety and confusion.  You may encounter conflicting information on the chance of suffering a re-rupture based on the graft source, as well as the potential downsides of a particular graft.  In this article, we will discuss the options, and I will outline the factors that I discuss with my patients to help them choose the best graft for their lifestyle and activity level.

Autograft vs. Allograft

ACL grafts are broadly characterized in to autografts and allografts.  Autograft tissue is obtained from another part of the patient’s own body, while allografts are obtained from a tissue donor.  Autograft tissue generally is harvested from around the injured knee.  In rare cases, autograft tissue may be taken from the patient’s non-injured knee. 

The advantages of autograft tissue are the following:

The disadvantages of autograft tissue include:

The advantages of allograft include:

The disadvantages of allograft include:

Generally speaking, I prefer autograft tissue over allograft tissue in most patients. It is more reliable, and ultimately, give me the confidence to allow the patient to return to their sport sooner.

There are three common sources for autograft ACL:

  1. Patella Tendon
  2. Hamstring Tendon
  3. Quadriceps Tendon

In the young, high-level, or profession athlete, I will almost exclusively use patellar tendon autograft.  This is the “gold standard” for ACL reconstruction with the longest track record of success.  Overall, it has the lowest re-rupture rate and lowest likelihood of stretching out over time.  The downside of this graft is that it is harvested from the front of the knee and can be associated with post-operative pain in certain patients.  This is usually due to poor rehab, and consequently, can be avoided in most cases with appropriate physical therapy and strenghtening of the muscles around the knee.

For patients who would like to avoid the possibility of anterior (front) knee pain, or already have a history of anterior knee pain, I would advise the use of a hamstring tendon graft or quadriceps tendon graft.  Both of these are excellent alternatives to the patella tendon graft. 

Hamstrings also have a long track record but do have a small increased risk of stretching out over time, particularly in young females.  Quadriceps tendon graft is a relatively new option but the short-term results are promising.  It is a large, strong graft, and is well suited for young patients, and it is also very useful in cases of revision (redo) ACL surgery where a hamstring or patellar tendon graft may have already been harvested.

I reserve allograft for patients who are low-demand or those who simply do not want to use their own tissue.

The common sources for allograft tissue include:

  1. Achilles’ Tendon
  2. Patella Tendon
  3. Hamstring Tendon

Each of these have very similar biomechanic and biologic properties.  If you choose to use allograft, speak to your doctor about the graft that she or he prefers, and the type of sterilization or processing that is utilized.  In general, grafts that are harvested in a sterile fashion and minimally processed have the best biomechanical properties.  Consequently, they may have lower re-rupture rates, but this is not definitively supported by the literature. 

To summarize, ACL surgery is not a “one size fits all” procedure.  The surgeon should work with the patient to determine which approach is best for them, and will yield the lowest risk of re-injury, and the greatest likelihood of return to sport.

Author
Frank Petrigliano, MD Dr. Petrigliano s a highly skilled orthopaedic surgeon and a specialist in sports medicine and shoulder surgery at the USC Epstein Family Center for Sports Medicine in Los Angeles, California. Dr. Petrigliano is the chief of sports medicine at USC and head team physician for the LA Kings professional hockey team.

You Might Also Enjoy...

Shoulder Fracture Q&A

Shoulder fractures are common injuries that are seen in a variety of age groups. Management depends on a number of factors.

Open Capsulolabral Repair for Shoulder Instability

While arthroscopic stabilization has become a popular option for treating the unstable shoulder, open capsulolabral repair remains the gold standard for preventing recurrent instability in the young, high risk patient.